Tuesday 06 Aug 2024 @ 13:10
Chatham House
Printable version

An illusion of mercy: Decoding Russia's prisoner swap strategy

EXPERT COMMENT

The prisoner exchange is a victory for diplomacy, but we should not assume that justice has prevailed.

On 1 August, Western countries and Russia conducted the largest prisoner swap since the Cold War. Through unprecedented international cooperation involving Germany, the US, Norway, Slovenia, Poland, and Turkey, it was possible to extract four Americans, five Germans, and seven Russians from Russian prisons, who were convicted on trumped-up charges in Russia and Belarus.

These were not only difficult negotiations but also a tough moral and ethical choice, which Russia deliberately imposed on the West. Although the prisoner exchange can rightly be considered a victory for diplomacy, we should not hastily declare that justice has prevailed. The Russian side held hostages to free their hitmen, spies, and hackers, while the West made a tough decision in favour of the freedom and lives of innocent people, not only their citizens but Russian nationals as well.

Click here to continue reading the full version of this Expert Comment on the Chatham House website.

 

Channel website: https://www.chathamhouse.org/

Original article link: https://www.chathamhouse.org/2024/08/illusion-mercy-decoding-russias-prisoner-swap-strategy

Share this article
RESEARCH EXPERTS EVENTS MEMBERSHIP ACADEMY ABOUT

 

Latest News from
Chatham House

The Houthis have cracked down brutally on Yemeni civil society. A strategic response is required

09/08/2024 12:20:00

The clampdown represents a new phase of authoritarian rule that will hinder the peace process and inhibit aid to ordinary Yemenis.

Sheikh Hasina’s departure exposes the fractures in Bangladesh’s politics

08/08/2024 13:10:00

The interim government must build political consensus to stabilise the economy and improve security. Other countries in the region should take note.

Does President Ruto have the means to appease Kenya’s protestors?

02/08/2024 12:20:00

Efforts to co-opt opposition and externalize blame are familiar tools in Kenyan politics, but may be ill-equipped to address the demands of a new youth protest phenomenon and the realities of Kenya’s fiscal struggles.

Israel’s strikes in Iran and Lebanon don’t hurt Hamas and Hezbollah much

01/08/2024 15:20:00

But they move Israel and the ‘axis of resistance’ closer to a wider war – a conflict that each side knows it cannot win.

A new SDR should make increased UK defence spending count

30/07/2024 09:20:00

While problems with procurement and recruitment may be being addressed, appointing external reviewers to the Strategic Defence Review is a creative way to overcome inter-service rivalry and build on deep experience.

Kamala Harris would bring greater foreign policy experience than most new US presidents

29/07/2024 09:20:00

Were she elected president in November, the vice president would likely oversee significant continuity with Biden’s foreign policy – except, perhaps, on Gaza.

The UK needs to move faster on nuclear energy cybersecurity

26/07/2024 16:15:00

The country’s nuclear energy industry has languished. The new government’s plans to revive it provide important opportunities, but cybersecurity needs bolstering.

Netanyahu’s speech sought bipartisan support by invoking the threat of Iran

26/07/2024 15:25:00

Israel’s prime minister offered little hope for Americans seeking a swift end to the war – and gave no detail on a dignified future for Palestinians.

The UK needs an India strategy that goes beyond the trade deal

26/07/2024 12:20:00

David Lammy will use his visit to renew momentum on the FTA negotiations, but he should also realize the strategic, economic and symbolic potential of a deeper UK-India relationship.

The Golden Thread: A study of the contribution of the project profession to the UK’s economy